훈족: 두 판 사이의 차이
내용 삭제됨 내용 추가됨
241번째 줄:
현대 학자들은 이 주장들을 상당히 부인한다.{{sfn|Engel|2002|p=2}}{{sfn|Lendvai|2003|p=7}}{{sfn|Maenchen-Helfen|1973|p=386}}{{sfn|Róna-Tas|1999|pp=426–427}} 이 연대기에서 발견된 훈족의 기원에 대한 주장에 대하여, [[쉬치 예뇌]]는 다음의 글을 남겼다:
<blockquote>물론 마자르인에 대한 훈족 기원은 프랑스인의 기원이 트로이인이라거나 다른 “오리고 겐티스”라는 당시에 많이 조작된 이론들처럼 가짜이다. 마자르인들의 진짜 기원은 핀우랄계 민족의 우랄계 분파에서 발생했고 동유럽의 스텝 지역을 떠도는 과정에서 이들은 다양한 (특히 이란계와 다른 튀르크계) 문화와 민족 요소들을 흡수하고, 훈족과 유전적 역사적 연관은 없었다.{{sfn|Szűcs|1999|p=xliv}}</blockquote>
Generally, the proof of the relationship between the [[Hungarian language|Hungarian]] and the [[Finno-Ugric]] languages in the nineteenth century is taken to have scientifically disproven the Hunnic origins of the Hungarians.{{sfn|Lafferton|2007|p=717}} Another claim, also derived from Simon of Kéza,{{sfn|Róna-Tas|1999|p=436}} is that the Hungarian-speaking [[Székely]] people of [[Transylvania]] are descended from Huns, who fled to Transylvania after Attila's death, and remained there until the Hungarian conquest of Pannonia. While the origins of the Székely are unclear, modern scholarship is skeptical that they are related to the Huns.{{sfn|Lendvai|p=24}} László Makkai notes as well that some archaeologists and historians believe Székelys were a Hungarian tribe or an Onogur-Bulgar tribe drawn into the Carpathian Basin at the end of the 7th century by the [[Pannonian Avars|Avars]] (who were identified with the Huns by contemporary Europeans).{{sfn|Makkai|2001|pp=415–416}} 전승과는 달리, the Székely were resettled in Transylvania from Western Hungary in the eleventh century.{{sfn|Makkai|2001|pp=416–417}} Their language similarly shows no evidence of a change from any non-Hungarian language to Hungarian, as one would expect if they were Huns.{{sfn|Makkai|2001|pp=414–415}}{{sfn|Engel|2001|p=116}} While the Hungarians and the Székelys may not be descendents of the Huns, they were historically closely associated with Turkic peoples.{{sfn|Lendvai|2003|pp=14–15}} Pál Engel notes that it "cannot be wholly excluded" that Arpadian kings may have been descended from Attila, however, and believes that it is likely the Hungarians once lived under the rule of the Huns.{{sfn|Engel|2001|p=2}} Hyun Jin Kim supposes that the Hungarians might be linked to the Huns via the [[Bulgars]] and Avars, both of whom he holds to have had Hunnish elements.{{sfn|Kim|2015|p=140}}
== 같이 읽기 ==
| |||